Because I liked
← The library

The private diary of Lyle Menendez

1993

  • case studies
  • murder
  • parricide
  • criminals
  • biography
  • true crime

The story

The personal story of Lyle Menendez is based on a four-and-a-half-year intimate correspondence with the author and covers the murders of Jose and Kitty Menendez by Lyle and his brother Erik and the court trials that ended in hung juries.

What it’s like

Confessional and unvarnished, written in the first person with the searching candour of a private notebook. The voice is close and insistent, circling the same memories, grievances and questions, so the pages feel like someone talking to himself late at night rather than telling a story with a neat shape. The texture is bare and sometimes clinical, as events are recounted flatly before slipping into raw emotion without warning. The atmosphere is claustrophobic and tense, with a family house and a courtroom that never let the reader breathe. The vibe is unsettled, self-absorbed and bleak, best suited to a quiet night alone when you want to sit inside a disturbing mind. Pacing is uneven and repetitive, mirroring obsessive rumination, and the emotional register is guilt, defensiveness and fear, following a young man stuck replaying a trauma and his own part in it. Intensity: the killings of his parents are discussed directly, with violence described but without gore or lingering graphic detail; the dread is psychological and heavy rather than gratuitous. Not gentle. For true crime readers who want an intimate, unreliable first-person account of a notorious case.

More books like The private diary of Lyle Menendez

Closest in mood, pacing and theme. Tell us why you loved The private diary of Lyle Menendezand we’ll explain which ones fit you.